Five Farms Irish Cream Liqueur Review | The Whiskey Reviewer The Irish Cream Liqueur wasn't thick or syrupy, but gave a soft velvety mouthfeel. Most of the flavors hit at mid-mouth both upper and lower. There were strong notes of cream, butterscotch and caramel. I also found some light chocolate and, finally, some good Irish Whiskey. At 34 proof, there wasn't any burn, but only a slight warming to ...